[Overhearing a little of that conversation, the brunette scoffed at the whole dream concept]

You're a few weeks too late for that- and if it was a dream, ideally you wouldn't be thinking of me.

[Then after a brief pause and canting his head to one side, a look of amusement on his features]

Though, I couldn't blame you if you did... but I'm not into that sort of thing.

[Look- he knows he's incredible, and modest. Giving the other male a once over with his eyes he noted the unusual garb, the creature wrapped around the neck, and most notably the heterochromatic eyes.]

You're also a little late for Halloween. [Presumably... since he honestly didn't know for certain if that month had passed]